Blog Hero

Can Eye Makeup Harm Your Eyes?

Book Your Appointment
A woman uses a brush to apply eye shadow to her eyelid

In the realm of beauty, the eyes are a focal point, often accentuated by various cosmetics designed to enhance their allure. But the pertinent question that lurks beneath the surface is: Can eye makeup harm your eyes? We’re here to dissect this question, exploring the unity and discord between eye makeup and ocular health.

While eye makeup can enhance our appearance and make us feel more confident, it’s crucial to take proper precautions and care when using it. From patch testing new products to properly removing them at the end of the day, these small steps can help keep our eyes healthy and beautiful. 

Now, let’s dive into the world of makeup. Eye makeup includes mascara, eyeliner, eyeshadow, and false lashes. These products often contain various chemicals and ingredients that can be harmful if used improperly or excessively or not removed before bed, which can lead to poor eye hygiene.

The Eye Itself

First and foremost, it’s essential to understand the anatomy and physiology of the eye. The eye is a delicate organ that requires careful attention and care. It contains numerous structures, including the cornea, lens, iris, retina, and optic nerve, all working together to create vision. Any damage to these structures can impact one’s vision significantly.

Understanding Eye Makeup

Eye makeup comes in various forms—mascara to lengthen lashes, eyeliners to define contours, and eyeshadows to add depth and colour. Common ingredients to watch out for include preservatives like parabens, fragrances, and compounds such as lead, which occasionally show up despite regulatory crackdowns.

Can Eye Makeup Hurt Your Eyes?

Concerns around eye makeup primarily revolve around infections, allergies, and irritation. Ill practices such as sharing makeup with others or using outdated products can escalate these risks. Studies published have assessed the microbial presence in expired makeup, validating concerns about infection risks.

A close-up view of a woman applying eyeliner with a brush

Types of Eye Makeup & Their Impact


Mascara wands are breeding grounds for bacteria, and each application carries a risk of eye infections like conjunctivitis. 

The Harm: Clumpy mascara may lead to lash fallout or blockage of hair follicles. 

The Safe Bet: Opt for mascaras free from harsh chemicals and apply cautiously to avoid contact with the conjunctiva.


Applying an eyeliner directly to the waterline can introduce contaminants directly into the eye’s surface. 

The Harm: Glitter particles or preservatives can cause scratches or allergic reactions. 

The Safe Bet: Seek out ophthalmologically tested eyeliners, and avoid the waterline for direct application.


The powdery nature of eyeshadows poses a threat if particles enter the eye

The Harm: Shimmer and glitter variants are notorious for causing irritation. 

The Safe Bet: Hypoallergenic and mineral-based eyeshadows may pose less risk thanks to their natural ingredients.

False Eyelashes 

False eyelashes can be a fun and dramatic addition to any makeup look, but they also have their risks. 

The Harm: Adhesives used to apply false lashes can contain harmful chemicals that may cause irritation or allergic reactions. Lash extensions can also put strain on the natural lashes and potentially cause damage. 

The Safe Bet: Opt for latex-free adhesives and use magnetic or non-toxic lash options instead.

Overall, it’s important to read ingredient labels carefully and do research on brands before purchasing eye makeup products. Choosing ophthalmologically tested, hypoallergenic, and mineral-based options can significantly reduce the risk of irritation or harm to your eyes. 

Best & Worst Eye Makeups for Eye Health

Our analysis points to the necessity of vigilance. Here’s what to consider:

The Worst Offenders:

  • Heavily fragranced products
  • Waterproof mascara (hard to remove, leading to vigorous rubbing)
  • Kohl eyeliners containing high levels of lead

The Top Choices:

  • Mineral-based eyeshadows (Pros: Natural ingredients. Cons: Limited colour range)
  • Water-based mascara (Pros: Less irritating, easier removal. Cons: May not be as long-lasting)
  • Clinically-tested eyeliners (Pros: Safety-focused, suitable for sensitive eyes. Cons: Potentially higher price tag)

Safer Alternatives for Eye Health

The rise of natural and hypoallergenic makeup offers respite for those seeking gentler alternatives. Brands are responding to a demand for eye-friendly products while maintaining beauty aspirations. Contemplating the transition? Look for products labelled ‘ophthalmologist-approved’ or ‘fragrance-free’ for a safer bet.

Awareness is the ally of well-being. It’s paramount to comprehend the interplay between eye makeup and eye health. If this insight has sparked a flicker of concern or curiosity, we implore you to introduce eye-friendly routines and alternatives into your beauty repertoire.

Always Remove Eye Makeup Properly

When it comes to removing eye makeup, gentle techniques are key. Avoid harsh rubbing or pulling on the delicate skin around the eyes, as this can cause wrinkles and sagging over time. Instead, opt for a gentle cleanser or makeup remover specifically designed for the eye area. And remember to always wash your hands before touching your face!

Avoid the Harsh Chemical & Irritants

Lastly, it’s important to note that not all eye makeup is created equal. Some products may contain harsh chemicals or irritants that can cause allergic reactions or irritation. When shopping for eye makeup, look for brands that use natural and gentle ingredients, and always read the ingredient list carefully.

The Ultimatum

Meticulous selection and application, alongside periodic cleansing of your makeup arsenal, can mitigate hazards. Investing in quality, regulated products and practicing disciplined makeup hygiene may prevent needless harm without stifling the joy makeup brings.

Explore Safe Makeup Alternatives Now

We encourage you to visit our eye care specialists for those who aim to stay abreast of issues bridging eye care and beauty or for those seeking personal advice on ocular health management. We are at the vanguard, ready to fortify your vision of health with technology and expert guidance.

For more information on eye care and safety, schedule your next eye exam with us at Arc Eye Care. We blend newer technologies with comprehensive care to keep your vision in prime focus.

Written by Amany Wissa

instagram facebook facebook2 pinterest twitter google-plus google linkedin2 yelp youtube phone location calendar share2 link star-full star-half star star-half chevron-right chevron-left chevron-down chevron-up envelope fax